A
83
Piccolino
3935 Amboy Road, Staten Island 10308
Mar 25, 2026 · No listed violations
Staten Island · Italian
Cleanest Italian in Staten Island
The top-ranked Italian restaurants in Staten Island by inspection record. 35 active spots, sorted by Clean Score.
Showing top 35 of 35 matches. Open the full directory →
A
81
Eat Italian
655 Rossville Avenue, Staten Island 10309
Feb 3, 2026 · No listed violations
A
81
Angelina's Ristorante
4446 Main Street, Staten Island
May 14, 2025 · No listed violations
A
80
Dani's
7331 Amboy Road, Staten Island 10307
Dec 4, 2024 · No listed violations
A
79
Panini Grill
538 Forest Avenue, Staten Island 10310
Mar 31, 2026 · No listed violations
A
79
Sapori Ristorante
3800 Richmond Avenue, Staten Island 10312
Mar 28, 2026 · No listed violations
A
79
Frank & Danny's Pizzeria
4369 Amboy Road, Staten Island 10312
Aug 13, 2025 · No listed violations
A
79
Villa Paradisio
145 Greaves Lane, Staten Island 10308
Sep 12, 2024 · No listed violations
A
78
Corrados Cucina
831 Arthur Kill Road, Staten Island 10312
Nov 7, 2024 · No listed violations
A
78
Ariana's
60 South Bridge Street, Staten Island 10309
Jan 23, 2020 · No listed violations
A
76
Campania Coal Fired Pizza
3900 Richmond Avenue, Staten Island 10312
Aug 29, 2024 · No listed violations
A
75
Il Sogno Italiano Ristorante
26 Jefferson Boulevard, Staten Island 10312
Jul 25, 2024 · No listed violations
A
73
Marina Cafe
154 Mansion Avenue, Staten Island 10308
Mar 26, 2025 · No listed violations
A
72
Aunt Butchies Of Brooklyn
4864 Arthur Kill Road, Staten Island 10309
Aug 28, 2025 · No listed violations
A
71
Brooklyn Italian Heroes
829 Annadale Road, Staten Island 10312
Feb 10, 2025 · No listed violations
A
68
Trattoria Toscana
4200 Hylan Boulevard, Staten Island 10308
Oct 19, 2023 · No listed violations
N/A
64
Patrizias Of Tottenville
4916 Arthur Kill Road, Staten Island 10309
Feb 2, 2026 · No listed violations
N/A
64
Ciro Pizza Cafe
862 Huguenot Avenue, Staten Island 10312
Aug 13, 2025 · No listed violations
N/A
63
Da Noi Ii
138142 Fingerboard Road, Staten Island
Oct 4, 2024 · No listed violations
N/A
62
La Bottiglia Bar & Restaurant
293 Port Richmond Avenue, Staten Island 10302
Apr 4, 2026 · No listed violations
N/A
61
O'Sfizio
4651 Hylan Boulevard, Staten Island 10312
Oct 7, 2025 · No listed violations
N/A
61
Amici Pizzeria
6309 Amboy Road, Staten Island 10309
Aug 7, 2025 · No listed violations
N/A
60
Giuliana Ristorante
4105 Hylan Boulevard, Staten Island 10308
Apr 29, 2026 · No listed violations
N/A
59
Pronto Pizza
738 Forest Avenue, Staten Island 10310
May 19, 2025 · No listed violations
N/A
57
Goodfellas Brick Oven Pizza
4029 Hylan Boulevard, Staten Island 10308
Oct 18, 2024 · No listed violations
N/A
57
La Fontana Sorellena
885 Annadale Road, Staten Island 10312
Oct 3, 2024 · No listed violations
N/A
57
Bella Mama Rose
266 Morningstar Road, Staten Island 10303
Aug 15, 2024 · No listed violations
N/A
54
Panino Rustico
895 Huguenot Avenue, Staten Island 10312
Oct 14, 2025 · No listed violations
N/A
50
South Fin Grill, The Vanderbilt
300 Father Capodanno Bouleva, Staten Island
Oct 24, 2025 · No listed violations
N/A
46
Mangia
7517 Amboy Road, Staten Island 10307
Mar 17, 2026 · No listed violations
N/A
46
Millie's Of Staten Island
185 Bricktown Way, Staten Island 10309
Aug 18, 2025 · No listed violations
N/A
42
Osteria Santina
502 Jewett Avenue, Staten Island 10302
Apr 4, 2026 · No listed violations
N/A
40
Coral Bay Cafe
722 Rockaway Street, Staten Island 10307
Apr 1, 2026 · No listed violations
N/A
36
Fiore Di Mare
227 Mansion Avenue, Staten Island 10308
Dec 15, 2025 · No listed violations
N/A
32
Don Roberttos
616 Forest Avenue, Staten Island 10310
Apr 13, 2026 · No listed violations